When the numbers tighten, almost every principal reaches for the same lever first.
The wage bill. Who can we do without. Who is carrying the lightest load. Can we run the department with one less.
It is the fastest lever and it is the most painful one, and for a lot of agencies it is the wrong one. Cutting staff buys you a quarter. Deciding what your business is actually for buys you the next five years.
So before you have that conversation with your property manager, it is worth asking a different question. Not how do we cost less. What is the real asset here, and what do we want it to do for us?
The Question Underneath the Staffing Question
Most agencies are two businesses wearing one brand. A sales business, which is volatile, personality driven and tied to the market cycle. And a rent roll, which is recurring, resilient and genuinely valuable to someone else.
When the market softens, the sales business is what hurts. The instinct is to trim the whole organisation to match. But the rent roll is usually the part that is still working, and it is almost always the part with a saleable value attached to it.
Which gives you a real choice. Restructure and ride out the cycle. Or release the value in the rent roll, in part or in full, and rebuild around what you actually want to be doing.
Neither answer is right in the abstract. The mistake is not choosing. The mistake is defaulting to the staffing conversation because it is the one in front of you.
Three Signs Selling May Be The Better Move
One. There is no succession plan, and no obvious successor.
If the honest answer to "who runs this in five years" is "me, still", you do not have a business, you have a job with overheads. Plenty of principals are comfortable with that, and that is a legitimate choice. But if you are only restructuring to keep a business alive that nobody is going to take over, you are spending money and goodwill to delay a decision rather than make one.
Two. The rent roll is the main asset, and you are propping it up with everything else.
Look at where the value in your balance sheet actually sits. If the rent roll is carrying the agency, and the agency is consuming the rent roll's margin to stay afloat, you are quietly spending the asset to fund the operation. A sale converts that asset into something you can use, while it is still intact and still attractive.
Three. The sales side is struggling and the fix keeps being next quarter.
Sales businesses do come back. But if you have been waiting two or three cycles for the recovery that funds the rest of the business, the rent roll is doing the work and taking none of the reward. A rent roll that is subsidising a sales business is not a strategy. It is a slow transfer of value out of the thing that works.
None of those three mean sell. They mean the staffing conversation is not the real conversation.
You Do Not Have To Sell All Of It
This is the part principals most often do not realise is on the table.
You can sell the rent roll and keep the sales business. You can sell part of the rent roll, release capital, and keep managing the rest. You can sell a geographic slice that never really fitted. The decision is not sell the agency or keep the agency. There is a lot of room in between, and that room is where most good outcomes sit.
A partial sale can take the pressure off without ending anything. It can fund the restructure you actually wanted rather than the one the cash flow forced on you. And it can be done while the rent roll is strong, which is the only time anyone pays properly for it.
One thing to get right if you go this way. If you are keeping the sales business, the restraint clause in that contract decides what your remaining business is allowed to do. We have seen restraints drafted so broadly that a seller who kept their sales business was effectively locked out of property management across a far wider area than they ever intended, because the clause never said what it was measured from. Our Selling a Rent Roll guide walks through how these deals are structured and where the value leaks.
The Cost Almost Nobody Prices In
Here is the thing that catches people, and it is the reason this article sits next to a staffing decision rather than apart from it.
If the buyer does not take your staff, the redundancy cost usually sits with you.
Principals routinely assume the team goes across with the rent roll. Sometimes they do. Often they do not, and nothing in a typical contract requires it. The buyer picks who they want, which is normal, and anyone they do not want stays with you.
Which means your exit number has to carry:
Redundancy pay
Notice periods
Accrued annual leave
Long service leave exposure
The superannuation and payroll timing around settlement
And it is not only the bill. If the redundancy process is not run properly, and these processes can have real lead times, you can add an unfair dismissal claim to the cost of your own sale. Smaller businesses have lighter obligations here, but lighter is not the same as none, and whether you qualify depends on how your group is structured rather than on how small the rent roll feels.
The pattern is predictable. It happens most where the buyer already has capacity in their own team, or where the rent roll is small enough that it does not justify extra people.
Case Study
The Property Manager The Buyer Did Not Want
A principal was selling a smaller rent roll while keeping the sales business, and assumed the buyer would take their property manager across. Nothing in the contract required it. The buyer could choose which staff they wanted, which is usual.
As the deal progressed, the buyer decided they had enough capacity already. The employee stayed with the seller. Redundancy pay, accrued leave and notice had never been in anyone's numbers, and the bill ran into tens of thousands of dollars, paid straight out of the sale proceeds.
On paper it was a good sale. The headline price only matters if it is the amount you actually keep.
Write The Staff Position Into the Contract
Two things would have changed that outcome, and both of them happen before anything is signed.
Ask early whether the buyer actually wants your people. Not at contract stage. At the first serious conversation. In medium and larger rent rolls, buyers usually want at least one key person for continuity and landlord relationships. In smaller ones, buyers often want the rent roll and not the people. Neither is good or bad. You just need to know which one you are dealing with while you still have leverage.
Then document it. Either as a transfer obligation in the contract, or as a known seller cost you have priced into the deal. What you cannot do is leave it as an assumption, because once terms are agreed there is no leverage left to renegotiate it.
The same goes for the commitments that do not disappear when you sell. Franchise agreements that need assigning or terminating. An office lease that does not line up with settlement. Fixed term software and trust accounting subscriptions. Records you are still required to keep, and the system access you have to pay for to keep them. If you are thinking about selling in the next few years, now is not the moment to sign a five year lease or a five year franchise agreement.
A Quiet Sales Market is Not the Same as a Quiet Rent Roll Market
This is where a lot of principals talk themselves out of a good decision.
When property sales slow, the assumption is that everything has slowed, including the appetite for rent rolls. That is not what we see. The two markets do not move together, because they are bought for different reasons.
Sales volumes follow sentiment. Rent rolls are bought for recurring income, for scale and for strategic position. We regularly see buyers executing deliberate growth plans, acquiring an office and then adding rent rolls to it, with clear targets for the number of managements they need. Those buyers are not waiting for the sales market to turn. They are building for the next cycle, and a well run rent roll with clean management agreements and a solid retention history is exactly what they want.
So the fact that your sales business is quiet tells you something about your sales business. It does not tell you what your rent roll is worth, or who wants it.
We are deliberately not quoting multiples here. They move, they vary by state and deal size, and a number from a blog is the worst possible basis for a decision this size. What is worth knowing is that the two markets are separate, and you should not assume one from the other.
Before You Decide Either Way
Work out what the rent roll is actually contributing, separately from the sales business. Many principals have never seen the two apart
Answer the succession question honestly. Who runs this in five years, and have they agreed to it
Get a view of the rent roll market, not the sales market, from someone who sees these transactions regularly
Price the staff position before you price the deal. Who the buyer wants, who they do not, and what the ones they do not want cost you
Check what you are locked into. Franchise, lease, software, and how long each runs
If selling is on the radar at all in the next 12 to 24 months, start tidying leave balances and management agreements now. Both affect what you walk away with
The point of this list is not to push you towards a sale. It is to make sure that if you do restructure, you are doing it because you chose to, with the alternative properly costed.
Key Takeaways
The wage bill is the fastest lever, not always the right one. Cutting staff reduces cost this month, but it can also strip out the people who hold your rent roll together, which is the part of the business still earning while sales are slow.
Most agencies are two businesses wearing one brand. Sales is volatile and market-dependent. The rent roll is recurring and resilient. Before you cut anything, work out which of the two is actually under pressure.
Three signs selling may be the better move: you have no succession plan for the rent roll, the rent roll is the main asset propping up a struggling sales side, or the fix for the sales business has been “next quarter” for several quarters running.
It is not all or nothing. A partial sale, or selling a geographic slice, can release capital while you keep operating. Check the restraint clause before you sign, because it may stop you doing the very thing you planned to keep doing.
Redundancy is the cost almost nobody prices in. If the buyer does not take your staff, redundancy pay, notice, accrued annual leave, long service leave, super and payroll timing all sit with you, along with unfair dismissal exposure if the process is handled poorly.
Deal with the staff position in the contract, early. Ask the buyer what they intend to do with your team, document it, and check what your franchise agreement, lease and software contracts commit you to beyond settlement.
A quiet sales market is not the same as a quiet rent roll market. The two move on different cycles, so do not price one off the mood of the other.
Next Steps
If you are weighing up a restructure against a sale, the useful thing is not an opinion on the market. It is knowing what your rent roll is worth, what the staff position will cost you, and what you would be free to do afterwards.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
-
Yes, and it is one of the more common structures we see. The thing to watch is the restraint clause, because it decides what your remaining business is allowed to do after settlement, and where. A restraint that is drafted loosely can stop you operating in areas you never intended to give up.
-
Only if the contract says so. In most contracts the buyer chooses which staff, if any, they want. If the buyer does not take someone, that person stays with you, and so does the redundancy cost. Ask the question early and write the answer into the deal.
-
Where an employee is not taken on by the buyer, redundancy usually sits with the seller, along with notice, accrued annual leave and any long service leave. Smaller businesses have lighter obligations, but whether you qualify depends on how your group is structured, so it is worth checking rather than assuming.
-
Not necessarily. Sales volumes and rent roll demand do not move together, because rent rolls are bought for recurring income and scale rather than sentiment. A quiet sales market tells you about your sales business, not about what your rent roll is worth.
-
Yes. A partial sale can release capital, reduce the operational load, and let you keep managing the part of the portfolio that suits you. It is often a better fit than an all or nothing decision, particularly if the pressure you are feeling is cash flow rather than a desire to exit.
-
Before. Even a term sheet labelled non binding sets expectations, and once a seller has signed one it becomes very hard to renegotiate retention, restraints, referral arrangements and staff assumptions. The leverage is all in the period before anything is agreed.
Jonathan Green – Principal, Realgate Legal
Jonathan Green is one of the Principals at Realgate Legal with a strong passion for both the real estate and legal industries. With over 16 years of experience, he has led his own firm, worked for a large national law firm, and served as Partner and Director of a busy Victorian real estate agency. As a Licensed Estate Agent, Jonathan understands the real world challenges his clients face, having worked directly within the industry. After selling his real estate business in 2021, he returned to full time legal practice, combining his expertise in law and real estate. Jonathan specialises in commercial law, property transactions, developments, rent roll sales, and leasing and conveyancing matters.
Boring legal stuff: This article is general information only and cannot be regarded as legal, financial or accounting advice as it does not take into account your personal circumstances. For tailored advice, please contact us. PS - congratulations if you have read this far, you must love legal disclaimers or are a sucker for punishment.